Uploaded image for project: 'Jackrabbit Content Repository'
  1. Jackrabbit Content Repository
  2. JCR-2321

ZombieHierarchyManager can return wrong child node entries for replaced nodes

    XMLWordPrintableJSON

Details

    • Bug
    • Status: Closed
    • Minor
    • Resolution: Fixed
    • core 1.4.11, 1.5.7, 1.6, 2.0-beta1
    • 2.0-beta1
    • jackrabbit-core
    • None

    Description

      The ZombieHierarchyManager currently implements the two getChildNodeEntry methods like this:

      1) look up child node in old, overlayed state, which might contain removed child nodes
      2) if not found, ask the super implementation (ie. get the child node from the up-to-date list)

      The purpose of the ZombieHM is to be able to return removed item ids from the attic. However, the behavior above is IMO wrong, as it should first find an existing child node with the given name (or id):

      1) look up child node in super implementation (ie. get the child node from the up-to-date list)
      2) if not found, look in the old, overlayed state if it might have been removed

      I was able to reproduce this issue when replacing a node (but note the custom access manager in 1.4.x used as explained below): create /replaced/subnode structure, save the session, remove the replaced node and add /replaced and then /replaced/subnode again:

      Node rootNode = session.getRootNode();

      // 1. create structure /replaced/subnode
      Node test = rootNode.addNode("replaced", NT);
      test.addNode("subnode", NT);
      // 2. persist changes
      session.save();

      // 3. remove node and recreate it
      test.remove();
      test = rootNode.addNode("replaced", NT);

      // 4. create previous child with same name
      test.addNode("subnode", NT);

      // 5. => gives exception
      test.getNode("subnode").getNodes();

      To complicate things further, this was only triggered by a custom access manager, and all based upon Jackrabbit 1.4.x. Back then (pre-1.5 and new security stuff era), the access manager would get a ZombieHM as its hierarchy manager. If its implementation called resolvePath() on the HM for checking read-access in the final getNodes() call, where the tree will be traversed using the getChildNdeEntry(NodeState, Name, int) method, it would get the old node id and hence fail if it would try to retrieve it from the real item state manager.

      Thus with a Jackrabbit >= 1.5 and 2.0 the above code will work fine, because the ZombieHM is not used.

      However, we might want to fix it for 1.4.x and also check the other uses of the ZombieHM in the current trunk, which I couldn't test. These are (explicit and implicit): ChangeLogBasedHierarchyMgr, SessionItemStateManager.getDescendantTransientItemStates(NodeId), ItemImpl.validateTransientItems(Iterable<ItemState>, Iterable<ItemState>) and SessionItemStateManager.getDescendantTransientItemStatesInAttic(NodeId).

      Attachments

        1. JCR-2321-branch-1.4.patch
          4 kB
          Alexander Klimetschek
        2. JCR-2321-trunk.patch
          3 kB
          Alexander Klimetschek

        Activity

          People

            alexander.klimetschek Alexander Klimetschek
            alexander.klimetschek Alexander Klimetschek
            Votes:
            0 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            0 Start watching this issue

            Dates

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved: