Uploaded image for project: 'Maven SCM'
  1. Maven SCM
  2. SCM-258

The perforce provider should be able to accept complex filespecs using a clientspec rather than the path in the SCM url

    XMLWordPrintableJSON

Details

    • Improvement
    • Status: Closed
    • Major
    • Resolution: Auto Closed
    • None
    • None
    • None
    • All OS, Maven 2.x using the SCM plugin to talk to perforce

    Description

      One of the strengths of perforce is the ability to do fairly complex actions with the clientspec.

      For example:

      1 - Checkout two file structures into one location:
      //depot1/tree1/... //client/project/tree1
      //depot2/tree2/... //client/project/tree2

      2 - Rename file structures at checkout time :
      //depot/tree/sample-configuration.xml //client/tree/configuration.xml

      The SCM URL format doesn't allow this (and implementing it would be difficult)

      Currently, the perforce provider doesn't seem to allow a way to use an existing clientspec (all codepaths seem to create a new clientspec based on the URL)

      If the provider could allow an existing clientspec to define the file structure, this functionality could be enabled.

      Testing:

      I don't have any JUnit experience, but I think this could be tested by:

      1 - Create a clientspec that defines some complex content, for example:
      //depot/project/src/... //clientspec/project/src/...
      //ThirdParty/... //clientspec/project/ThirdParty/...

      2 - run "mvn scm:checkout" and all files should be checked out.

      Implementation Ideas:

      I can see multiple ways of doing this, depending on the restrictions/conventions required

      A - Use the existing "bootstrap/target/checkout" dynamic directory structure

      • Using "p4 client -o" with the given/predefined/assumed clientspec, alter the p4_root (the line containing "Root:") and do a "p4 sync -f"
        (Definition of the clientspec ideas defined separately below)

      B - Assume the clientspec has a defined "Root:" and use that for the purposes of "locating" files (needed for tag/editing/checkin purposes)

      • As I'm only checking out, I really don't know how this would affect a checkin

      C - Separate from above, how to define which clientspec to use:

      • In the SCM URL, perhaps with scm:perforce:[username@]host:port:@clientspec_name
        (the second @ being a placeholder for a delimiter)
      • As an environment variable (perhaps the existing maven.scm.perforce.clientspec.name,
        enabling this functionality (re-use vs. re-create) with a different property
      • Defined in the settings.xml or in the pom.xml in the SCM configuration properties

      I'm sure more details will be required, this is only what I've identified within my particular situation.

      Attachments

        Activity

          People

            Unassigned Unassigned
            dlacoste Dana Lacoste
            Votes:
            4 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            4 Start watching this issue

            Dates

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved: